gametechmods
Off-Topic => Real Robotics => Real Robotics Discussion => Topic started by: Enigm@ on October 23, 2010, 05:32:03 PM
-
Just an experiment. Heres a fight if you have not seen it:
<object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/Ko0yM5eTdiY?fs=1&hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/Ko0yM5eTdiY?fs=1&hl=en_US" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>
-
Storm 2 clearly won
Typhoon hardly got any good hits in and spent half the match running away with the spin motor broken...
-
who the heck voted for typhoon
-
Storm II should have won and would have won but that fight was 7 (?) years ago so why does it matter?
Anyways the match should have ended when the arena was broken because it was a saftey hazard. Scratch that I couldn't find any thing in the Robot Wars 2003 rules about arena breaches or match restarts.
-
Storm II.
Tyyphoon II was nothing special.
-
I'd say Storm II as well. For the most part, Typhoon spent its time running away in most of its matches.
-
but that fight was 7 (?) years ago so why does it matter?
its pointless if we debate it as we cant change anything but its nice to hear peoples opinions on the subject
-
Exactly.
-
And here, they'd made a massive fanfare of the piece of metal that came off of Storm II, whereas the Typhoon team lied and said that their robot was "Fighting Fit", even after their spinner mechanism broke again and they lost their left-hand drive, even after they were permitted to fix it after they broke the arena.
-
I'd say Storm II as well. For the most part, Typhoon spent its time running away in most of its matches.
True, but it could of also been spinning up the shell, you know?
Ofcourse, when the weapon motor broke that couldn't be the case.
-
it ran away to spin up
though in its first rumble and the grand final it ran away due to the weapon breaking
it was on the run from the restart in the grand final, storm 2 was on top the whole time,
And here, they'd made a massive fanfare of the piece of metal that came off of Storm II,
and the claimed "skillful dodging" by Typhoon 2 when it hit the edge of the pit and missed the wall.
-
Yeah.. after watching the Extreme series rerun on Dave it became apparent JP wasn't as aware of what's going on then I remembered.
Guess it is a family show though and a specialist commentator might of had a few problems with phrase clarity or other things; certainly doesn't feel like RW without JP and Craig.
-
Storm 2 should have clearly won that match.
at the point where Storm 2 rammed Typhoon 2 against the pit release button... well, at that point, you can see something getting from underneath Typhoon 2. after that, it didn't even start spinning again.
"Typhoon 2 can't get up to full spinning speed." JP said. "where did you see it spinning then?" was my thought then.
-
we all know why Storm 2 should have one but I would like to hear from one of the 5 why they think Typhoon correctly won (like a proper reasoning)
ts obvious the damage on Storm 2 was self inflicted and they made a big deal about it, I mean they never handed one of Hypnodisc's opponents pieces of their robot after a match (probally becasue there was to many to count but still :P)
-
Storm 2's treatment was disgusting. First the Producers forced the team to put on an active weapon, then they put it in a Heat with 2 feared spinners Shredder and Supernova. Then they tried to disqualify it after its fight with Firestorm, claiming it never used its weapon and supposedly broke the rules. Then they raised the pit back up for Tornado, then they allowed Typhoon 2 to repair its weapon and didnt let the Judges know about this or the dislodged drivechains at the end of the fight.
And If I would be going to be a millionaire when I'm adult. I promise, I PROMISE! That Robot Wars Will be back!
-
Storm 2's treatment was disgusting. First the Producers forced the team to put on an active weapon, then they put it in a Heat with 2 feared spinners Shredder and Supernova. Then they tried to disqualify it after its fight with Firestorm, claiming it never used its weapon and supposedly broke the rules. Then they raised the pit back up for Tornado, then they allowed Typhoon 2 to repair its weapon and didnt let the Judges know about this or the dislodged drivechains at the end of the fight.
Quoted for truth. And then there's also how the audience were booing so much at the decision that they had to edit cheers in to make Storm II look like the bad guys!
+1 for the valid points raised, by the way :claping
-
Yeah, it was pretty bad, the boos must have been huge, they're still obvious with the cheers dubbed over.
I'm actually surprised they didn't play on it in a more possitive way, make a proper grudge out of it, have the storm team go on a proper crusade against the typhoon team and the producers, then again i'm starting to make it sound like wrestling :laughing
It's kinda funny how they rigged it for tornado to win, but one season later and they're doing all they can to stop the rammer type bots winning :laughing
And didn't one of the judges say something about regeting giving it to typhoon later?
-
Yeah, it was pretty bad, the boos must have been huge, they're still obvious with the cheers dubbed over.
I'm actually surprised they didn't play on it in a more possitive way, make a proper grudge out of it, have the storm team go on a proper crusade against the typhoon team and the producers, then again i'm starting to make it sound like wrestling :laughing
It's kinda funny how they rigged it for tornado to win, but one season later and they're doing all they can to stop the rammer type bots winning :laughing
And didn't one of the judges say something about regeting giving it to typhoon later?
That last part is true, actually! Once the judges found out about the damage Typhoon 2 had a little while later, they actually sent the Storm team individual letters of apology :approve:
-
Yeah, it was pretty bad, the boos must have been huge, they're still obvious with the cheers dubbed over.
I'm actually surprised they didn't play on it in a more possitive way, make a proper grudge out of it, have the storm team go on a proper crusade against the typhoon team and the producers, then again i'm starting to make it sound like wrestling :laughing
It's kinda funny how they rigged it for tornado to win, but one season later and they're doing all they can to stop the rammer type bots winning :laughing
And didn't one of the judges say something about regeting giving it to typhoon later?
That last part is true, actually! Once the judges found out about the damage Typhoon 2 had a little while later, they actually sent the Storm team individual letters of apology :approve:
Awww, that made me quite happy actually.
What happened to stop them from seeing that damage though, the show showed them giving the bots a good look over :confused:.
I think I heard that the typhoon team did cover up parts actually, but I don't know if that's true because surely they would have had any prize money taken off them.
-
Yeah, it was pretty bad, the boos must have been huge, they're still obvious with the cheers dubbed over.
I'm actually surprised they didn't play on it in a more possitive way, make a proper grudge out of it, have the storm team go on a proper crusade against the typhoon team and the producers, then again i'm starting to make it sound like wrestling :laughing
It's kinda funny how they rigged it for tornado to win, but one season later and they're doing all they can to stop the rammer type bots winning :laughing
And didn't one of the judges say something about regeting giving it to typhoon later?
That last part is true, actually! Once the judges found out about the damage Typhoon 2 had a little while later, they actually sent the Storm team individual letters of apology :approve:
Awww, that made me quite happy actually.
What happened to stop them from seeing that damage though, the show showed them giving the bots a good look over :confused: .
I think I heard that the typhoon team did cover up parts actually, but I don't know if that's true because surely they would have had any prize money taken off them.
I don't know...especially when they threw that chain up to the control pods. And it's terrible to realise that the Typhoon team were practically lying to save face and get the money, really. And then at the same time, they had the nerve to make out they were completely undamaged! If I were Gary Cairns (The team captain), I'd be ashamed.
-
Well, it's possible that the producers helped them cover it up to the judges and what not somehow.
I mean when you think about it, not a single proper spinner won the championship before typhoon.
Yes, I know tornado technically was a spinner, but it's ramming and pushing power was the thing that made it competitive, plus it needed to use a stupid frame in order to beat a far superior bot.
Spinners seemed to be always the bridesmaid never the bride, hypno-disk,pussycat, disk-o-inferno and ofcourse my favourite spinner 13 black were all worthy bots that could have easily been champions but for whatever reason didn't get too.
I think it's possible that the producers desperately wanted a proper spinner champion, perhaps to encourage more spinner designs (especially shell or full body spinners, something that was a lot more popular in the u.s but, IIRC, not so common in the u.k RW)
-
They were probabley trying to encourage more damaging weapons (like spinners) because flippers really didnt do any damage you could see.
-
Storm II was a rammer, so it focussed more on internal than external damage, shaking loss vital components via energy transferral.