gametechmods
Off-Topic => Chatterbox => Topic started by: System32 on September 18, 2009, 02:18:26 PM
-
The Debating League is the hub for all DEBATE:... Threads in GTM. To debate, ask me and I will start the thread with all participants ready.
Rules:
- If you are not in the debate, don't post in it. PM me or add a comment here.
- No personal attacks while debating. This does NOT include:
Bringing up posts from other threads to back a claim or disprove another's claim.
I will ask for judges. These people may judge debates from a NEUTRAL AND HONEST VIEWPOINT.
Judges who are not judging a discussion may join in.
Debate thread request form:(POST NOT PM)
Debate name:
Summary:
Particapants for:
Against:
Judges:
Naryar
Urjak
40757
Debates:
Crawlers In tournaments. (https://gametechmods.com/forums/showthread.php?p=67259)
...
...
...
...
-
I shall be the Supreme Justice.
-
I will be judge, if this works, because debates do not like restraints.
It's like putting Chaos in between walls and thinking he won't get out.
-
I guess I'll join, because there are no debate teams at my school.
-
I'll be a judge. I am pretty neutral when it comes to looking at a debate or argument I am not actually a part of.
-
OK. Any requests for debates?
-
OK. Any requests for debates?
^^^ I think I got a good one to start off with thats always a hot topic: Are Crawlers fair in Tourney's:smiley:.
-
I second that.
-
*Is supposed to be neutral on a debate about crawlers*
...
...
...
...(http://th08.deviantart.net/fs49/300W/i/2009/195/9/e/Fuuuu_by_Ku127.png)
...Oh hell, i'll try.
-
Lol Nary you kill me:smiley:, This is my opinion on it: I feel that every bot has a weakness and Also if it follows the Tourney Guidelines(Rules) then it should be fine. Also I notice alot of Exp. builders don't like them and despise them, What I don't get sense you guys are so exp. in building bots can't you guys just build a bot that Captilizes on there Weakness.(Not a personal attack on Exp. builders because I respect all of you and you guys have helped me alot in my showcase:approve:.)
-
I'll be the third judge.
-
Not to whack you Viper or anything, but this isn't the thread, we're not started yet.
However we will definitely start by crawlers, and yes, you're in the debate.
-
What form of debate will this take?
How are people going to present their opinions?
-
Well, The judges Will be selected by how much people know them.
For the first debate: Crawlers.
Shall it be 1v1, 2v2 or 3v3?
Also, to be nice to Nary, Urjak is the judge.
The opening statement is for whoever posts first, then rebuttal and the Other opening statement, then rebuttal and rebuttal to the rebuttal until the judge finds a clear winning point.
So, who wants to be in the debate? (STATE FOR OR AGAINST.)
Also, the Judge may create the thread.
-
I will be in the debate, FOR.
Definitely 1 v 1.
-
Awwww I wanted for.
2 vs. 2 then.
-
Does anybody want to be on my team for: Are Crawlers Fair in Tourney's(considering they follow the rules for the Tourney's)
-
Sage, Trumpetguy and Viper will be FOR.
Naryar, ... and ... will be against?
-
Me obviously
-
I will be FOR crawlers.
-
Sage, Trumpetguy and Viper will be FOR.
Naryar, ... and ... will be against?
I thought Nary is a judge, or does one of the other 2 take his place during the debate:?.
-
Damn it guys, I want a 1 vs 1 argument. I know what i can say and how to defend it, but I can't control what you guys say and if you say something wrong the opposing team will capitalize on that and we would probably lose.
1 VS 1
-
IDK, plan everything out through PM, Hamachi, or IM?
-
Agree with Sage. A 2v2 would probably be doable, but anything above that is pushing it.
-
NVM Im out because I want to see Nar vs Sage *gets popcorn*
-
Very Well.
-
I'LL ARGUE ABOUT ARGUING!!!! GRAHHH
Edit: Oh hey, I was here for a year on the 16th.
-
The Threads got interesting already.
-
Possible next debate: do popups nescerrilly have the weapon going up?
-
Possible next debate: do popups nescerrilly have the weapon going up?
What?
-
Well people say that if the weapons come overhead it`s a hammer while something coming from underneath is a popup.
-
Umm.. I don't think there will be enough people interested enough to debate for this. Maybe a debate on the extent of the AAM use would work.
-
^^i was thinking to BFE as well.
About crawlers... do what you want guys, but still you can bet i'll be PISSSSED if one of my true popups loses to some gay crawler in a DSL tournament in an enclosed arena.
-
I think it should become a general rule like "DSL is always realistic unless a tournament specify's otherwise"...
Crawlers should become outlawed in DSL unless a tournament specifically allows them
as for stock its really an anything goes version of RA2 so nothing can really be done to stop them
-
Okay, AMM is the next debate.
Judge: Naryar
For: Reier
Against: Sage
-
I WOULD enter,But with naryar as judge: 0_>
-
i will enter against AAM.
-
Ok, anyone for?
-
NOBODY IS FOR AAM!!!
-
Fine, I'm in.
MUAHAHAH
-
Very well then.
-
New debate, homosexuality and marrage!
(Reier can't get involved for being a ****ing moron.)
Judge: Me.
For: Sage and ...
Against: ... and ...
-
i think acams is the one who is against it
-
for.
-
I'll let 407507 be the judge. I am not interested in such topics.
-
I'm not really interested in being a judge anymore so you can give it to somebody else.