The rep should not be removed-- it helps new people find a role model. The GTM policy should be based on thid Wikipedia policy:
http://goo.gl/hxazdExamples of good-faifth reasons:
Decent bot in BBEANS you got there. (+1)
You deflammed a topic! That is very hard. (+1)
Your advice helped --GTM member here-- win a challenge agianst the high-ranked --Insert member with coloured name here--! (+1)
Please, can you stop spamming? You got on the Watched list for that. (-1)
Constantly attacking --Insert GTM member here--; you constantly spammed his inbox with links to shock sites. Do it again or you might get even permabanned. (-1)
Shouting racist comments and slurs to --insert Mexican or Black/African-American member--. He/She feels offended to your posts. (-1)
Examples of bad faifth reasons: (Notice how one has -1 despite positive comment.)
You are a good friend to me. (+1)
You have a PS3-- just like me. (+1)
At the new Wal-Mart, there is the new Call of Duty games on the shelf! Go get them before their gone! (+1)
I dislike black people-- that's why I dislike you! (-1)
Destroying Absolute Chaos-- I can't beat him! (-1)
How much crack have you took today? (-1)